Low Cost Lead Free Solution Evaluation for Electronic Consumer Applications

Member Download (pdf)

Lead products are no longer an option if you want to export to the EU market. RoHS regulations requiring the manufacture of
lead-free electronic products by July 2006 are pushing the industry to evaluate and find lead free solutions soon. There are
several important issues in undertaking a transition to lead free,including: 1) finding PCB materials and plating finishes that
can withstand the high reflow and wave temperatures of lead free alloys,2) selecting lead free alloys that have similar or
better quality and reliability characteristics than SnPb,3) assessing whether the lead-free components can withstand high
reflow temperatures,4) finding a cost effective solution,and 5) understanding and solving the challenges of the lead-free
process on PCBs,components and solder joint quality. In this paper we address these issues by evaluating a) two PCB
materia ls - FR1 and FR4,b) PCB plating finish – OSP and Ni/Au,c) lead-free alloy Sn 3.5Ag0.5Cu (SAC) and 58Bi42Sn,
and d) the number of reflows (single -sided vs. double-sided). We evaluated 58Bi42Sn eutectic alloy as a solution for those
components that cannot withstand the high temperature process of SAC alloy. Our goal is to determine a cost effective
solution for a low temperature application. Different reliability tests,warpage measurements,and cross sections were used to
evaluate each configuration.

Author(s)
Krishna Darbha,Nicoletta Sangalli
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2005

Practical Lead-Free Implementation

Member Download (pdf)

Environmental regulations are forcing the elimination of lead (Pb) from electronic equipment. 2005 will be the year that
many electronics assemblers will be transitioning their soldering processes from traditional tin-lead alloys to lead-free alloys.
Many alternatives to tin-lead have been proven to be technically viable in relatively small volumes,but the implementation of
the new processes in high-volume manufacturing presents a series of new challenges to engineering and operations personnel.
This paper reviews six major considerations for implementing lead-free soldering processes in a manufacturing operation:
equipment evaluation,materials compatibility,separating and identifying the two separate processes,training,validating the
process,and beginning continual improvement. Details of each consideration are discussed and summarized in a checklist
format at the end of the paper.

Author(s)
Chrys Shea,Bruce Barton,Joe Belmonte,Ken Kirby
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2005

High Yields and Low Costs Liquid Resists

Member Download (pdf)

In the multilayer PCB industry,the process of making the inner layer is the first step in a number of complex steps that
results in the production of a printed wiring board. This imaging manufacturing step comprises of a number of subprocesses
that together allow for the metal interconnect pattern to be formed. The steps by themselves are small and can seem
irrelevant,however a good balance of precision and synchronization of all processes is required to guarantee a high yielding
reproduction of the circuitry pattern. To ensure the process has the ability to function in any of the selected production
environment the selection of raw materials is key to the functionality of the chosen photoresist.
20 years ago,the Inner Layer Photoresist market is being dominated by dry film. However in recent years a significant move
towards liquid photoresist has been noted. The main drive for liquid resist was the increased needs for resolution without the
need for investment in new equipment. The cost of dry film is relatively high and cannot match the low cost and high
resolution of today’s liquid resist market offerings.
The industry is demanding a leading edge liquid resist that can balance the formulation of the raw materials used to a ensure a
low cost resist formulation that can maintain stable,reproducible,high yielding processes that work in conjunction with the
various equipment sets used in the industry today.
In this paper,the first section will be allocated to a discussion on the various equipment / process issues. The second section
will be focused on the trade offs in formulation to meet those requirements. The final section will discuss the engineering of a
formulation that address the issues discussed.

Author(s)
Danny K. L. Cheung,Brian D. Amos,Tina Marabello,Kevin Horgan,Kevin Cheetham
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2005

The Development of Dry Film Photoresist with 15um Lines and Spaces Resolution for Semi-Additive Processing

Member Download (pdf)

Next generation IC substrate designs will feature higher interconnect density and faster signal speed than current designs.
Circuitization of these substrates uses copper pattern plating followed by differential etching,which is called “semi-additive
processing”. Dry film photoresist is well suited for semi-additive processing because it is available at the proper resist
thickness with excellent thickness uniformity.
The performance requirements for dry film photoresist for semi-additive processing are defined as process compatibility,
environmentally friendly chemistry,ease of handling,and high yield. According to “voice of the customer”,key dry film
attributes are high resolution,good adhesion to a variety of copper surfaces,good line reproducibility,high yield,and clean
stripping after plating with conventional alkaline solution,that is compatible with existing aqueous waste water treatment.
A novel dry film photoresist for the next generation IC substrate substrates was developed with new polymer technology for
binder polymer and monomer combinations and novel photo initiator systems. This paper covers dry film performance
derived from requirements voiced in the VOC.

Author(s)
Hidetaka Uno
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2005

The Latest Technical Trend of Dry Film Photo Resist

Member Download (pdf)

This paper describes the performance of several types of the most advanced Dry Film photo Resist (DFR),for producing
high-density package substrates and chip on films (COF).
1) High resolution type DFR,which achieves very fine conductive patterns less than L/S=15/15um by semi-additive plating
process,is discussed.
2) High photosensitive type DFR is presented,which is used for Direct Imaging (DI) exposure systems expected to be
applied to MPU package substrates. In the DI exposure systems,the irradiance of exposure lights affects the DFR resolution.
Selecting a new initiation agents,which has high absorbance at h-line (405nm) for higher photo reaction efficiency,
accomplishes the resolution of L/S=15/15um with 25um DFR thickness. This type of DFR also has high resistance for plating
by using such monomers that increase of photo-reactive groups inside. The current target is L/S=10/10um resolution at quite
low exposure energy,10mJ/cm2.
3) Ultra thin DFR below 5um for high density COF and TAB by subtractive method gives higher performance than
conventional liquid photo resists. The DFR,which has demonstrated excellent 2um resolution and adhesion with 2um
thickness on the experimental basis,extends the application field to near one micron scale,from the previous ten micron
scale.
4) Other grades,thick layer DFR (120um thickness) for electroplating wafer bump formation and DFR for sandblasting
which achieves dry etching of wafers,ceramics and glasses,are also introduced in the paper.

Author(s)
Hiroaki Tomita,Toru Mori,Shoichiro Tonomura
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2005

Trimming Embedded Resistors Using Available PWB Equipment Technology

Member Download (pdf)

By using two existing pieces of common printed wiring board manufacturing equipment,embedded resistor manufacturers
can obtain laser trim results similar to the trimming obtained using a specialized probe card based laser trimmer. Existing
electrical test equipment can be programmed to first measure the values of plated additive resistors manufactured on circuit
board inner layers. Next,this value information is programmed into the software of a laser routinely used to drill microvias
for circuit boards. A computer routine calculates the amount of the resistor that needs to be removed to adjust each resistor to
the required design value. This trimming is then conducted on the actual inner layer.
Advantages of this technology include eliminating the manufacture of probe cards for each new circuit design,and utilizing
existing machines for this new technology task. While accuracy of trim with this “off line” machine may not be quite as
precise as active trimming with probe cards,the accuracy is sufficient for many of the 5-10% resistor values needed for such
design applications as digital signal termination. Plated additive resistors,with their uniform thickness across each resistor,
are particularly easy for this technology combination to trim.

Author(s)
Dennis Fritz,Dave Sawoska,Frank Durso,Ted Martin,Gabor Kardos,Leah Hauswirth,Chip Hasey,Craig Coffman
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2005

Novel Substrate for Use as Embedded Capacitance: An Easy to Process Higher Dk Material

Member Download (pdf)

We have previously published our work on developing thin substrates for use as embedded capacitor layers. Both unfilled
and filled materials were characterized in regards to performance,reliability and manufacturability. It was demonstrated that
higher capacitance density came at the expense of ease of processing.1 A new substrate was developed to address this issue.
As previously shown,high speed digital circuits benefit primarily from the capacitive layers being as thin as possible. For
mobile electronics,however,they want the highest capacitance density so they can remove the most discrete capacitors. With
both these markets in mind,a thin substrate with higher Dk than unfilled systems was developed. A major design objective
was to be able to etch both sides of the substrate at the same time (like traditional power/ground layers).
We will discuss the experiences of PWB shops in processing the material and review the results of the various reliability
studies. Also,test vehicles have been processed for testing at high frequencies to compare against the other capacitive
materials. It will be demonstrated that this new substrate has excellent electrical properties (such as a DK of 10 and the ability
to pass 500 volt High-Pot) while being able to be readily manufactured using typical inner-layer processing.
In addition we have developed a method,which utilizes our highest Dk material,which is compatible with HDI processing.
This process can be used to embed capacitance within an organic chip package.

Author(s)
John Andresakis,Takuya Yamamoto,Pranabes Pramanik,Nick Biunno
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2005

Embedding Passive and Active Components in PCB - Solution For Miniaturization

Member Download (pdf)

The miniaturization of the electronics continues and requires the utilization of inner space of a PCB for component
placement. The embedding of the passive components inside the PCB has already been used in the industry. To meet the
requirement of the marketplace the new technologies like embedded actives Integrated Module Board (IMB) has been
developed. With traditional technologies it has become more difficult to increase the packaging density. In the Integrated
Module Board technology active components are embedded inside a printed circuit board (PCB) or other organic substrate.
The IMB process combines PCB manufacturing,component packaging and component assembly into a single manufacturing
process flow. The embedded passive technology and IMB technology enables high interconnection density with good
reliability.
The integration of components into the PCB level makes the manufacturing of the PCB challenging. In this paper an update
of embedded passive technology will be presented together with an overview of IMB technology,its technological capability
and electrical performance.

Author(s)
Tarja Rapala-Virtanen,Kimmo Perälä,Risto Tuominen,Petteri Palm
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2005

The Importance of CTE in Multi-Layer Registration and Improved Measurement Methods

Member Download (pdf)

The current worldwide market for printed circuit boards is approximately $40 billion,with the multi-layer printed circuit
boards (MLB) comprising approximately 40% of the market. One of the most perplexing processing problems is poor
registration in multi-layer lay-ups. This leads to hundreds of millions of dollars in scrap and lost productivity,and
compromises performance in high-end applications. Significant progress has been made over the years to identify the critical
components responsible for improved reproducibility and reliability. However,as pitch (conductor spacing) becomes finer;
the registration problems of multi-layer board fabrication become more severe. Better analytical tools are needed to meet this
new challenge.

Author(s)
Donald E. Yuhas,Carol L. Vorres,Howard R. Elliott,Kathy Kelly
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2005

A Comparison of PCB Adhesion Test Methods and Adhesion Promoters

Member Download (pdf)

Interest in the adhesive strength of PCBs has recently come to the forefront of the industry. This has been driven by the
advent of lead free soldering processes that severely stress the mechanical properties of the board. For sometime,the
accepted test method for measuring adhesion in the PCB industry has been the widely used peel strength test. At the same
time,it has been common knowledge within the industry that this technique has been less than adequate in guarding against
delamination failures during reflow and wave soldering. In recognition of this deficiency,a new test was recently introduced
and the test method is now a part of IPC 650; the so called “T260 Method” in which a thermal event is imposed that causes a
delamination of the test specimen.
This paper presents a statistical comparison of the two test methods. The correlation is found to be very poor indicating the
failure mechanisms measured by the two tests are structurally dissimilar. An analysis is then carried out to mathematically
define the stress fields created by the two tests. As suspected,the stress fields are significantly different. Finally,these two
tests are used to compare the strength of two different copper adhesion promotion chemistries,the Black Oxide coating and
an Alternative coating. Most empirical observations have found that the performance of the coatings is equivalent; however,
only the T260 test agrees with this observation.

Author(s)
J. Lee Parker,Patrick Brooks
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2005