Reliability Impact of Frequent Power Cycles on Base Printed Wiring Boards High Density Packaging User Group (HDP)
The High Density Packaging (HDP) user group has completed a project to evaluate the impact on field reliability of more frequent thermal cycling over more narrow operating temperature ranges such as occur in today’s data center or cloud environments. In the past, printed wiring board field reliability testing assumed just one thermal cycle per day based upon systems begin completely shut off in the evening and circuit temperatures dropping to ambient temperature before being turned on again every morning. Whereas many systems today are rebooted and/or go into a lower power “sleep” mode ten or more times per day. In addition to the above new field application environments, laminate materials today have higher filler content and their mechanical characteristics are different from the less thermally robust phenolic and dicy-based laminate materials used prior to the widespread use of high temperature lead-free solder alloys in board assembly. Note that this project concerns the reliability of the bare printed wiring board and has no connection with any earlier “power cycling” projects which evaluated the reliability of various SMT or PTH solder joint alloys.
The goal of this project was to determine the relative impact on field reliability of more frequent thermal cycling over a more narrow temperature range with less frequent temperature cycling over a larger temperature range using at least two of the laminate materials available today. Interconnect Stress Testing (IST) is one of the recognized standards for measuring the expected reliability of bare printed wiring boards. Although there are other methods, the more practical IST method was selected for determining the impact of these new field conditions on printed wiring board reliability.
For both laminate material test lots, which had several physical differences, the results show that more frequent thermal cycling can significantly affect long term field reliability even with reduced temperature cycling ranges.