Effects of Conductor Surface Condition on High Frequency Loss
Efforts to reduce high frequency signal losses associated with dielectric materials have driven development and
commercialization of more cost effective low loss laminate materials. These developments have been facilitated by the use of
a variety of standardized dielectric test methods.
As dielectric losses are reduced,the relative contribution of conductor materials to overall loss increases. In order to better
understand the implications of conductor material and surface finish choices,efforts have been made to quantify the impacts
of these factors on loss.
While conductor material and surface finish influences may be directly measured using printed wiring board test structures,
interpretation of the results are complicated by the influence of both the laminate material and the particular geometry
selected for the test structure (microstrip versus stripline versus differential pair). The results of such measurements
accurately reflect the specific test geometry examined,but are difficult to extrapolate to different systems.
An alternative test approach has been identified which provides a measure of conductor performance,decoupled from both
system geometry and the influence of laminate material.
The basic test method described in IPC TM-650 2.5.5.5.1. (Stripline Test for Complex Relative Permittivity of Circuit Board
Materials to 14 GHz) has been modified by comparing the results obtained using ideal smooth copper conductors and with
those obtained with samples of alternative conductor materials,while maintaining a constant dielectric material. Changes in
the resonator loss factor between the two tests allow calculation of the relative performance of the alternative material versus
the ideal conductor.
Using this test method,the performance of a number of surface finishes,PWB foil treatments and inner-layer adhesionpromotion
processes relative to a control smooth copper surface are reported.