Design of Experiments to Assess the Solderability of Various Printed Wiring Board Finishes
There are two main driving forces that are causing the electronics industry to take a look at alternatives to hot air solder leveling (HASL) as a surface finish for printed wiring boards (PWB). First,finer pitch array packages like micro-BGA and chip scale packages are being used in increasing volumes and for a broader variety of devices. With reducing pitches,and thus smaller ball diameters,it becomes necessary to have a predictably flatter surface in order to achieve a consistently more reliable solder joint. The inherent nature of the HASL process to leave inconsistent and uneven topographical profiles of the PWB pad surface,has been well observed and documented. Alternative finishes such as organic solderability preservative (OSP),immersion tin,immersion silver,electroless nickel/immersion gold (ENIG),etc.,have been proven to provide the flatness desired – several orders of magnitude flatter than HASL. The second reason to consider HASL alternatives is the move toward lead-free electronics,particularly in Europe and Japan. With legislation already approved in Europe and a strong focus on environmental marketing in Japan,the demand on PWB fabricators to produce “unleaded” product will no doubt see a marked increase over the next several years. In the United States,organizations such as IPC,the National Electronics Manufacturing Initiative (NEMI),and others have been heavily involved in research activities related to lead-free materials over the last several years. Although the US has not produced any legislative mandates (as of this writing) on the removal of lead from electronics,research activities are ongoing.