Measuring the Impact of Test Methodsfor High-Frequency Circuit Materials

Member Download (pdf)

High-frequency materials are characterized by several important parameters, including the dielectric constant or relative permittivity (εr) and the dissipation factor (Df). For those parameters to have meaning for circuit designers, they must be measured using methods that deliver accurate, repeatable results. However, circuit materials are characterized by many different test methods: For measuring εr, IPC has 12 different test methods.  Many other organizations, including ANSI and IEEE, have their own test standards for characterizing εr.Each measurement method provides detailed insights into the properties of the material it is testing, and the results of each test method may be correct, but they also may not agree. What follows is a review of different methods for measuring εralong with useful modifications and even some suggestions for new Dk measurement approaches.

Author(s)
John Coonrod
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2020

A Cost-Effective Method for Accurate PCB Impedance Simulation of Any Specific Stack-Ups

Member Download (pdf)

This paper analyzes the reasons of inaccurate PCB impedance simulation of the traditional simulator and introduces a novel and cost-effective method for accurate PCB impedance simulation of any specific stack-ups. The new method doesn't need to extract material properties from prototype boards or empirical modified DK from PCB Fabs. The test results show the new method & tool have better precision simulation ability with deviation less than 2.5%, compared with traditional simulation tool. It can meet the requirement of less than 5% tolerance impedance to match the high speed & high frequency PCB design, and consequently leads to a more cost-saving and time-saving method to rapidly occupy the market.

Author(s)
Terry Ho
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2020

Optimization of PCB SI Coupon Design that Minimizes Discontinuity through Via-In-Pad Plated Over (VIPPO) Technique

Member Download (pdf)

The importance of signal integrity is emphasized as signal speed increases, and higher frequencies are applied. The PCB manufacturer uses SI coupons that can replace the in-product circuit to measure and calculate the signal loss. In this study, we tried to minimize the discontinuous path of Delta-L coupon by using the VIPPO (Via In Pad Plated Over) technique to improve the signal integrity. We compared the VIPPO-applied design that has minimal discontinuity with the conventional Delta-L design. In order to minimize discontinuity, circuits connected to pads and via holes were removed from the outer layer, and the pads were designed directly above the via holes. First of all, we simulated the optimized design that eliminated discontinuities using Signal Integrity Software, Simbeor. Second, we measured and verified Delta-L by using Introbotix's Accu-prober program. In the future, higher measurement frequencies will further increase signal loss due to unnecessary pathways and discrete signals, therefore minimizing the effects of discontinuity will be an important issue, and using the VIPPO technique will help to improve signal integrity.

Author(s)
Juhee Lee, Kyeongsoo Kim, Namdong Lee, Kyungsoo Lee
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2020

Acid Copper Electroplating Processes With Excellent V-Pit Resistance for Flash Etching

Member Download (pdf)

Driven by rapid changes and markets, the electronics industry has seen massive growth over the past few decades. The short product life cycle has pushed PCB fabrication technology to its limits. Industry leaders continuously push innovations to be more competitive in the electronics manufacturing market space. In this era of electronics miniaturization, technologies that generate high yields with lower costs, such as High-Density Interconnects (HDI), Semi-Additive Processing (SAP), and Modified Semi-Additive Processing (mSAP), are widely utilized. Most of these technologies are not new to the electronics industry, but are common processes in IC substrate and PCB fabrication. They help maximize the PCB real estate usage by allowing fabricators and designers to build up multilayer devices. Figure 1 shows examples of multilayer designs that require multiple metallization and etching steps to achieve the desired designs and thicknesses.

Etching has become a crucial aspect of PCB fabrication. With the increasing number of layers, the risk of failure grows exponentially. Hence, a great deal of attention has been paid to the Cu deposit and how it reacts to etching. Higher technologies require many etching steps, during which uneven etching, pinhole formation, pitting or V-pitting, become significant issues [1]. These defects can cause severe reliability issues for the final product [2]. Innovative Cu electroplating solutions are required that produce Cu deposits with higher resistance to V-Pitting. Fabricators currently resolve these issues by baking the plated panels for several hours, which increases the process cost and negatively affects production output. The focus of this study was to investigate the underlying mechanism of V-pitting and to develop a process to withstand or resist the pitting. This phenomenon is called “V-piting“ due to the characteristic shape of the pits.

The process discussed here also showed excellent via fill and through hole (TH) plating capability in the same plating bath for core layers of HDI and IC substrates in a one-step DC process. Vias were filled with 49,000 psi, elongation > 25%). A bath aging study and a DOE were completed for the process. SEM, XRD, and FIB data will also be presented

KEYWORDS: Flash Etching, V-pit, Reliability, Via Fill, Trough hole, Pattern Plating, Metallization.

Author(s)
Saminda (Sam) Dharmarathna, Sean Fleuriel, Eric Kil, Charles Bae, Leslie Kim, Derek Hwang, William Bowerman, Jim Watkowski, Kesheng Feng
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2020

Non‐Destructive Measurement Improvements in Determining the Phosphorus Content in Electroless Nickel Deposits for ENIG And ENEPIG Using XRF

Member Download (pdf)

Phosphorus content in electroless nickel deposits, for PCB and electronic connectors, is a critical factor in controlling the nickel layer’s corrosion resistance and solderability. Improvements in X‐ray fluorescence (XRF) hardware and fundamental parameter software algorithms now allow for the direct measurement of the percent phosphorus (%P) under gold layers.

Author(s)
Devarsh Shah, Robert Weber
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2020

Comparing the Reliability Performance of Electroless Palladium and Autocatalytic Gold in Production Environment

Member Download (pdf)

The development of nano-scale surface finishes over copper pads such as Electroless Palladium and Autocatalytic Gold (EPAG) has been evolving in the recent years due to ever increasing demands in terms of reliability, component miniaturization and signal transmission.

Scope of this paper is a full investigation of the production reliability of Electroless Palladium and Autocatalytic Gold. As soldering and bonding are both possible with EPAG and of special interest in the microelectronics industry, the solder joint reliability (SJR) and bonding results will be evaluated. Increasing I/O counts have led to ever decreasing cross sectional contact areas or, by default, an increase in solder performance expectations. The evaluation of this high solder joint reliability demand was satisfied by cold ball pull testing and high-speed shear testing (HSS).

To examine EPAG’s bonding abilities, the as-received (ASR) mode, as well as the aged condition at 150°C for 4h, were applied. Also, general storage reliability of the EPAG finish was simulated via ageing for 100 to 1000 h after bonding, assessing EPAG’s bonding performance over a broad process window. EPAG’s gold wire bond performance will be rated against ENEPIG finish. In addition to soldering and bonding, the reliability of a final finish is also reflected in its wetting behavior and adhesion; therefore, solder indicator, dewetting and solder spread testing were performed. Reliability against external, harsh conditions was tested via salt spray testing and compared to other common final finishes.

Author(s)
Tom Scimeca, Sandra Nelle, C Daczkowski, B Schafsteller, G Ramos
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2020

ENEPIG -How the Process Characteristics Influence the Layer Performance

Member Download (pdf)

Electroless Nickel/Electroless Palladium/Immersion Gold (ENEPIG) is a well-accepted and established finish for high performance applications. The properties of the coating are determined mainly by the characteristics of the palladium layer and the type of the gold electrolyte used and have been investigated in various studies. 

In general, PdP or pure Pd coatings are available, which differ not only in their coating properties but also in their plating behavior and in the properties of the electrolytes used. The subsequent gold layer might be deposited by either an immersion type electrolyte or alternatively a reduction assisted gold bath which also will impact the final layer properties.

Looking back on a long experience of ENEPIG plating with pure Pd as well as with PdP, this paper will focus on the comparison of pure Pd and PdP deposits and the interaction with the gold electrolyte type in use.  The initial start reaction of the Pd bath is studied and the difference in the behavior of the PdP and pure Pd electrolyte was compared. Knowing that the crystallinity of the deposited layer is different for a pure Pd deposit compared to a PdP layer, the porosity was determined with the help of electrochemical as well as microscopical techniques to identify and judge the probability of a corrosive attack of the gold electrolyte to the underlying nickel. To be able to reliably judge the corrosive attack of the gold electrolyte, the corrosion was statistically evaluated by rating the number of corrosion events as well as the depth in the nickel deposit.

When comparing the performance of the finishes, considering the properties of electrolytes and the plating conditions, it becomes obvious that there is no single solution for all requirements. Rather, that the process allows manifold options to define the best conditions to the customer needs.

Key Words ENEPIG; Corrosion; Porosity; Solder Joint Reliability

Author(s)
Britta Schafsteller, Sandra Nelle, Gustavo Ramos, Dirk Tews, Mario Rosin
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2020

Reliable Nickel-Free Surface Finish Solution for High-Frequency-HDIPCB Applications

Member Download (pdf)

The evolution of internet-enabled mobile devices has driven innovation in the manufacturing and design of technology capable of high-frequency electronic signal transfer.  Among the primary factors affecting the integrity of high-frequency signals is the surface finish applied on PCB copper pads –a need commonly met through the electroless nickel immersion gold process, ENIG. However, there are well-documented limitations of ENIG due to the presence of nickel, the properties of which result in an overall reduced performance in high-frequency data transfer rate for ENIG-applied electronics, compared to bare copper.

An innovation over traditional ENIG is a nickel-less approach involving a special nano-engineered barrier designed to coat copper contacts, finished with an outermost gold layer. In this paper, assemblies involving this nickel-less novel surface finish have been subjected to extended thermal exposure, then intermetallics  analyses, contact/sheet resistance comparison after every reflow cycle (up to 6 reflow cycles) to assess the prevention of copper atom diffusion into the gold layer, solder ball pull and shear tests to evaluate the aging and long-term reliability of solder joints, and insertion loss testing to gauge whether this surface finish can be used for high-frequency, high density interconnect (HDI)applications.

Key words: surface finish, ENIG, nickel-less technology, high reliability, robust solder joint, intermetallics.

Author(s)
Kunal Shah
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2020

Effect of QFN I/O Pad Solder Paste Overprint on Thermal Pad Void Reduction

Member Download (pdf)

QFN-Quad Flat No-lead SMT-surface mount technology components continue to be increasingly used and also becoming smaller for applications further requiring a high level of thermal performance and reliability.  QFN device thermal pad regions have been observed w/ excessive void densities >30% in area, which limits the thermal conductivity or performance of the device and often requires subsequent costly rework.  Voids also become more dominant for smaller devices as the surface area of the thermal pad regions decrease, but voids may not correspondingly reduce in size or density. Using various reflow profiles, solder paste volumes and over-print values showed a statistically significant reduction of large voids and void density using the solder paste over print method. In addition, void formation and escape paths were demonstrated using x-ray imaging technology equipment that can be programmed to simulate an actual SMT surface mount technology reflow profile on a thermal platform or hot plate and provide real-time X-ray imaging recording the materials physical and void behavior.

Author(s)
Norman J. Armendariz
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2020

IPC E-Textiles 2023 Conference: IPC Issues Call for Participation

IPC is now accepting abstracts for IPC E-Textiles 2023, the international conference for the e-textiles industry, to be held live and in-person on Monday, January 23, 2023, in San Diego, California, in conjunction with IPC APEX EXPO 2023, the industry’s premier conference and exhibition for the electronics industry.

IPC E-Textiles 2023 is a multidisciplinary technical conference, providing an excellent opportunity for the e-textiles industry to learn, network, and collaborate on this vastly expanding technology space. By aligning IPC E-Textiles 2023 with IPC APEX EXPO, speakers and attendees will also have the opportunity to participate in IPC E-Textiles Committee standards meetings and take advantage of all events and education offered during IPC APEX EXPO.

IPC invites innovators and technologists from the e-textiles supply chain and academia to submit an abstract for a technical presentation during the conference. The IPC E-Textiles 2023 Program Committee seeks abstracts in the following topic areas:

  • E-Textiles Success Stories
  • Reliability and Standards
  • Economic and Business Aspects
  • Futuristic Thinking

Within these main topic areas, abstracts can focus on validation of product, washability, design, supply chain issues, innovations in materials, production, software and programming, and sustainability.

A 250-word technical conference abstract should describe significant results from experiments and case studies, emphasize new techniques, discuss trends of interest and contain appropriate technical test results.

Technical conference paper abstracts are due August 1, 2022. To submit an abstract or course proposal, visit https://www.ipc.org/ipc-e-textiles-2023.

IPC also announces the IPC E-Textiles 2023 Program Committee, which will shape the technical deliverables and format for this exciting and educational event:

  • Vladan Koncar, Ph.D. – University of Lille – Ecole Nationale Supérieure des Arts et Industries Textiles (ENSAIT)
  • Pratyush Rai, Ph.D. – Nanowear, Inc.
  • Sahar Rostami – Myant
  • Yolita Wildman Nugent – Betazip, LLC

For questions about the call for abstracts or interest in exhibiting at IPC E-Textiles 2023, contact Chris Jorgensen, IPC director, technology transfer, at ChrisJorgensen@ipc.org.