Solder Graping Issue Analysis
A solder graping issue affected multiple units during the production process. Solder graping is a phenomenon where small, un-melted solder particles are trapped on the surface of the joint, creating a rough, uneven texture[1]. An extensive analysis was conducted, including visual inspection, cross-sectional examination, Scanning Electron Microscopy coupled with Energy Dispersive X-ray Spectroscopy (SEM/EDX), and X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS). The solder joints themselves were confirmed to be in acceptable condition. The root cause was identified as excess tin oxide on the Printed Circuit Board (PCB) pad surfaces, which the flux was unable to effectively clean during the reflow process. Additionally, higher reflow temperatures exacerbated the graping effect, making the solder joints appear defective. To validate the integrity of the affected components, thermal shock tests with 2 group of settings as required by the assembly, were performed, along with a greater number of cycles, ensuring the functionality and reliability of the parts. After passing all post-test inspections, the solder joints were determined to meet the proper reliability accordingly. The analysis concluded that solder graping is not an inherent defect in the solder joint or materials but rather a process indicator related to surface conditions. Addressing this issue involves optimizing flux activity and temperature control in the reflow process, as well as ensuring proper PCB pad surface conditions. The outcome reinforces the importance of process control and proper processing of the assemblies in ensuring solder joint quality and avoiding false defects in production.