Comparative Analysis of Solder Joint Degradation Using RF Impedance and Event Detectors
Under cycling loading conditions,solder joints are susceptible to fatigue cracking,which often initiates at the surface where the strain range is maximized. Event detectors have been widely used to detect failure of solder joints during reliability testing. These devices monitor DC resistance using very high sampling rates,thus allowing failure to be defined on the basis of a minimum number of samples that exceed a failure threshold. Event detectors excel at recording rapid,intermittent changes in resistance and identifying a DC open circuit,which is the typical criterion for failure. However,event detectors are not sensitive to early stages of degradation,because changes in resistance under cyclic loading conditions do not occur until a crack has propagated almost all the way through a solder joint,and because their sensitivity to small changes in DC
resistance is adversely affected by temperature variations and electromagnetic interference.
RF impedance monitoring offers a highly sensitive means of detecting interconnect degradation. Due to the skin effect,a
phenomenon wherein signal propagation at high frequencies is concentrated near the surface of a conductor,even a small crack initiating at the surface of a solder joint raises the RF impedance. Thus,RF impedance monitoring can detect early stages of solder joint degradation long before it results in a DC open circuit. In order to compare the respective sensitivities in detecting solder joint degradation between RF impedance and event detectors,mechanical fatigue tests have been conducted with an impedance-controlled circuit board on which a surface mount component was soldered. During cyclic loading,simultaneous measurements were taken of DC resistance and the reflection coefficients obtained from time domain reflectometry (TDR) as a measure of RF impedance. The TDR reflection coefficients were consistently observed to increase in response to early stages of solder joint cracking prior to the first failure detection of an event detector. The results demonstrate that RF impedance monitoring has the potential to predict and prevent failures of electronic products due to solder joint cracking by providing a warning that an interconnect has begun to degrade.