Novel Approaches for Minimizing Pad Cratering

Member Download (pdf)

With the electronic industry moving towards lead-free assembly,traditional SnPb-compatible laminates need to be replaced with lead-free compatible laminates that can withstand the higher reflow temperature required by lead-free solders. Lead-free compatible laminates with improved heat resistance have been developed to meet this challenge but they are typically more brittle than SnPb laminates causing some to be more susceptible to pad cratering. In this paper,two novel approaches for minimizing pad cratering will be discussed. Preliminary results which validate the two approaches will also be presented.

Author(s)
Chen Xu,Yuan Zeng,Pericles A. Kondos,Yunhu Lin
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2014

Pad Cratering Susceptibility Testing with Acoustic Emission

Member Download (pdf)

Pad cratering test methods have been under development with the emergence of this laminate fracture defect mechanism. In additional to ball shear,ball pull,and pin pull testing methods,the acoustic emission method is being developed to evaluate
laminate materials’ resistance to pad cratering. Though the acoustic emission (AE) method has been proven to be able to detect pad cratering,no study has reported which AE parameters are good indicators for the susceptibility of PCB laminates to pad cratering. In this study,six different laminates subjected to three different pre-conditioning (multiple reflow) cycles have undergone the four-point bend testing. Four AE sensors were used to monitor pad cratering during the bend test. Several AE parameters including amplitude in dB level,the energy,and the location of each AE event under different load levels are recorded. Location analysis shows the majority of AE events are concentrated in the largest BGA package in the
test vehicle,which indicates that pad cratering is elevated with the larger size of BGA package due to high stress concentration. Both the number of AE events and the cumulative energy of AE events at a given applied load show that Laminate F is prone to pad cratering. However,there is no statistically significant difference in the lowest applied load to detectable AE among these six laminates. The ranking of the six laminate materials is different using different test methods. The most effective test method for predicting pad cratering susceptibility is inconclusive from this study.

Author(s)
Wong Boon San,Richard Nordstrom,Julie Silk
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2014

Numerical Study on New Pin Pull Test for Pad Cratering Of PCB

Member Download (pdf)

Pad cratering is an important failure mode besides crack of solder joint as it’ll pass the regular test but have impact on the long term reliability of the product. A new pin pull test method with solder ball attached and positioning the test board at an angle of 30º is employed to study the strength of pad cratering. This new method clearly reveals the failure mechanism. And a proper way to interpret the finite element analysis (FEA) result is discussed. Impact of pad dimension,width and angle of copper trace on the strength is included. Some findings not included in previous research could help to guide the design for better performance.

Author(s)
Billy Hu,Jesus Tan
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2014

Development,Testing and Implementation of SAMP-Based Stencil Nano Coatings

Member Download (pdf)

Stencil nanocoatings have demonstrated significant improvements in numerous aspects of solder paste printing,including print yield,transfer efficiency,print definition and under wipe requirements. By lowering the surface energy of SMT stencils,they reduce flux bleed out around the perimeters of apertures and enable cleaner paste release during stencil-PCB separation.
With several years of commercial success behind the original nanocoating materials,a new generation has been developed that improves upon many of the characteristics of the original formulations. Advancements in durability,detectability and cost boost the overall performance of these flux-repellent stencil treatments. Numerous tests have been performed to characterize stencil nanocoating materials throughout their development cycles and quantify their actual performance in SMT production environments. Laboratory tests have used liquid contact angles as response variables to characterize chemical and abrasion resistance and overall repellency. Production environment print tests have used automated solder paste inspection (SPI) to quantify volume repeatability,transfer efficiency,wipe frequency and overall print yields. These studies have focused on the end results of coating durability and print quality improvements,but have not explored the relationship between flux flow and surface energy modifications on the underside of the stencil. The novel test approach reported in this paper used solder paste treated with UV tracer dye to help image the flow of the flux on the bottom of the stencil (fig 1). This paper reviews the test methods and results,and describes the chemical structure of Self Assembling Monolayer Phosphonate (SAMP) nanocoating materials and their influence on the solder paste printing process. The discussion concludes with an overview of related applications of SAMP treatments in the SMT assembly,including printer tooling and accessories,area array/BTC rework stencils and jigs,and placement nozzles.

Author(s)
Chrys Shea,Ray Whittier,Eric Hanson
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2014

Quantifying Stencil Aperture Wall Quality

Member Download (pdf)

The goal of this study was to develop a method by which stencil aperture wall quality can be inspected,and the results quantified. Additionally,we hope to establish a correlation between the stencil wall quality and the paste release performance.
Stencil quality studies have traditionally focused on release data as the main method of gauging stencil fabrication quality. While some studies have included SEM images to aid in the assessment of stencil aperture wall quality,none have provided a method for quantifying the stencil wall smoothness. In this study,we will measure aperture walls of stencils using a confocal white light sensor with a 3 micron spot size and 0.02 micron depth resolution. The results will be quantified as average surface roughness (Sa). The surface roughness of various stencil fabrication methods will be measured and compared. Vendor claims of the quality of various materials,such as 304 Stainless,more expensive premium foils and nickel,will be assessed as will different fabrication methods including laser cutting,e-form and nano coating. In order to understand how wall roughness impacts stencil performance,a paste release study will also be conducted. A single BGA pattern will be printed on a glass slide and the paste release will be measured. This study will be of interest to both fabricators and users of stencils.

Author(s)
Christopher Tibbetts,Michael Antinori
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2014

Print Performance Studies Comparing Electroform and Laser-Cut Stencils

Member Download (pdf)

There has been recent activity and interest in Laser-Cut Electroform blank foils as an alternative to normal Electroform stencils. The present study will investigate and compare the print performance in terms of % paste transfer as well the dispersion in paste transfer volume for a variety of Electroform and Laser-Cut stencils with and without post processing treatments. Side wall quality will also be investigated in detail. A Jabil solder paste qualification test board will be used as the PCB test vehicle. This board has a wide range of pads ranging from 75 micron (3 mil) squares and circles up to 300 micron (12 mil) squares and circles. There are also long rectangular pads with spacing’s as low as 75 micron (3 mil). A total of 12 stencils,four stencils of different stencil technologies with three different coating configurations,will be tested as described in 1-4 below:
1- Electroform w/o Nano Coat and with and Nano Coat A and Nano Coat B
2- Laser-Cut Electroform foil w/o Nano-Coat and with Nano Coat A and Nano Coat B
3- Laser-Cut Fine Grain SS w/o Nano Coat and with Nano Coat A and Nano Coat B
4- Laser-Cut Fine Grain SS with Electropolish and Nickel plating,w/o Nano Coat and with Nano Coat A and Nano Coat B
A 100 micron (4 mil) thick stencil is used for all 12 stencils yielding Area Ratios ranging from .31 to .1.21.

Author(s)
Rachel Miller Short,William E. Coleman,Joseph Perault
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2014

Advanced Thermal Management Solutions on PCBs for High Power Applications

Member Download (pdf)

With increasing power loss of electrical components,thermal performance of an assembled device becomes one of the most important quality factors in electronic packaging. Due to the rapid advances in semiconductor technology,particularly in the regime of high-power components,the temperature dependence of the long-term reliability is a critical parameter and has to be considered with highest possible care during the design phase.
Two main drivers in the electronics industry are miniaturization and reliability. Whereas there is a continuous improvement concerning miniaturization of conductor tracks (lines / spaces have been reduced continuously over the past years),miniaturization of the circuit carrier itself,however,has mostly been limited to decreased layer-counts and base material thicknesses. This can lead to significant component temperature and therewith to accelerated system degradation.
Enhancement of the system reliability is directly connected to an efficient thermal management on the PCB-level. There are several approaches,which can be used to address this issue: Optimization of the board-design,use of base materials with advanced thermal performance and use of innovative buildup concepts.
The aim of this paper is to give a short overview about standard thermal solutions like thick copper,thermal vias,plugged vias or metal core based PCBs. Furthermore,attention will be turned on the development of copper filled thermal vias in thin board constructions. In another approach advanced thermal management solutions will be presented on the board level,exploring different buildup concepts (e.g. cavities). Advantages of cavity solutions in the board will be shown,which not only decrease the thermal path leading from the high power component through the board to the heat sink,but also have an impact concerning the mechanical miniaturization of the entire system (reduction of z-axis). Such buildups serve as packaging solution and show an increase in mechanical and thermal reliability.
Moreover,thermal simulations will be conducted and presented in this paper in order to reduce production efforts and to offer optimized designs and board buildups.

Author(s)
Gregor Langer,Markus Leitgeb,Johann Nicolics,Michael Unger,Hans Hoschopf,Franz P. Wenzl
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2014

Optimizing the Insulated Metal Substrate Application with Proper Material Selection and Circuit Fabrication

Member Download (pdf)

The ever expanding growth in the use of insulated metal substrates (IMS) in power electronics requires a focus on material and mechanical configuration for each application. By optimizing the material makeup and printed board format,performance and reliability expectations can be further achieved. The thermal performance and electrical isolation needs are driven by the power requirements,but considerations of temperature range,mechanical durability and format,along with the physical package surrounding the substrate must also be managed. With a variety of material configurations and circuit format capabilities,the choices become a balancing of options to maximize performance and minimizing cost through Design For Manufacturability (DFM) in the circuit board fabrication. These challenges present the IMS printed board fabricator with material selections and fabrication processes unlike those for other printed board or ceramic applications.

Author(s)
Dave Sommervold,Chris Parker,Steve Taylor,Garry Wexler
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2014

Method for the Manufacture of an Aluminum Substrate PCB and its Advantages

Member Download (pdf)

RoHS legislated restrictions on the materials used in electronics manufacture have imparted significant challenges on the electronics industry since their introduction in 2006. The greatest impacts have been felt by the mandated elimination of lead from electronic solder followed by the demand for the elimination of haloids from flame retardants used in traditional PCB laminates. In the years which have followed the electronics industry has been beset with a host of new challenges in its effort to comply. Failure mechanisms,both new and old,have surfaced which demand solution and the industry suppliers and manufacturing technologists have worked diligently to remedy those vexing faults through the development of a wide range of new materials and equipment for both board manufacture and assembly,along with modifications to the processes used in the manufacture and assembly of printed circuit boards.
Most of the problems which have confronted the electronics manufacturing industry have related to the solder assembly process. Lead-free solders were advertised early on as a drop-in replacement for traditional tin lead solders however field experience proved is not to be the case. The tin rich alloys along with the higher temperatures which were required for assembly cause the industry to scramble for solutions to such problems as champagne voids,poorer wetting,brittle solder joints,copper dissolution,tin whiskers,head in pillow,greater vulnerability to damage caused by explosive outgassing of absorb moisture in packages among others including cleaning of baked on fluxes following the high temperature assembly process. Lead-free solder also had spillover effects on the PCB laminate material itself as manufacturers experienced delamination and degradation of the resins used in circuit construction. One more recently encountered problem is a phenomenon referred to as pad cratering wherein resin beneath the copper land to which a component is attached is actually torn loose from the surrounding resin breaking through the copper and causing an open.
In this environment,an alternative approach to manufacturing electronic assemblies has been conceived and is presently being developed. The new method in simplest form is one which eschews the use of solder and is predicated on the use of aluminum substrates which house fully tested and burned in components to create what can be best described as a component board wherein the terminations of the components are proximately planar with the surface of the aluminum. In subsequent processing the aluminum component board is first coated with an insulating material and then circuits which interconnect the components are applied using buildup technologies. An example of a test vehicle is shown in Figure 1.

Author(s)
Joseph Fjelstad
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2014

Combination of Spray and Soak Improves Cleaning under Bottom Terminations

Member Download (pdf)

The functional reliability of electronic circuits determines the overall reliability of the product in which the final products are used. Market forces including more functionality in smaller components,no-clean lead-free solder technologies,competitive forces and automated assembly create process challenges. Cleanliness under the bottom terminations must be maintained in harsh environments. Residues under components can attract moisture and lead to leakage currents and the potential for electrochemical migration.
Removing flux residues from under bottom terminations is extremely challenging. As components decrease in size,the Z-axis gap height also reduces. When the Z-axis gap is less than 3 mils (75um),the capillary and wetting action of flux during reflow underfills the bottom termination component with flux residue. To clean,the cleaning fluid and mechanical action must reach,wet and dissolve the soil in order to create a flow channel. Once a flow channel is created,the soils under the terminations are effectively cleaned.
The purpose of this research study is to evaluate innovative spray and soak methods for removing low residue flux residues and thoroughly rinsing under Bottom Termination and Leadless Components. Targeted spray nozzles deliver the cleaning agent to the soil. Following this interaction with an agitated soak allows the flux residues to dissolve. Targeted spray nozzles rapidly move the dissolved residues and fully clean residues under terminations. This designed experiment will study process parameters in order to draw inferences from the data findings.

Author(s)
Mike Bixenman,Julie Fields,Eric Camden
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2014