Case Study – “Limitations of DI-Water Cleaning Processes”
While most cleaning processes in the global electronics manufacturing industry still rely on cleaning with DI-water only (for OA flux removal),recent studies suggest that water is beginning to reach its cleaning limitation,favoring the use of chemically assisted cleaning processes. The increased use of water-soluble lead-free solder requires more activators and higher soldering temperatures,which result in more burnt-in fluxes and produce water insoluble contamination. DI-water alone has a limited to no ability to solubilize non-ionic residues on the board’s surface.
These findings coincide with the use of smaller,more densely packed components which further limit the effectiveness of pure DI-water. Due to its high surface tension of over 70 dynes/cm,water cannot effectively penetrate underneath low standoff components. Chemistry assisted cleaning processes,however,can reduce the surface tension to 30 dynes/cm and below and therefore eliminate penetration problems.
This technical case study complements the authors’ initial in-house findings by comparing them to actual production assemblies and conditions. The lead engineering team at a participating customer site designed this comprehensive blind study to determine removability with DI-water versus various chemistry supported systems. The findings revealed significant experimental data,which shed much needed light on this emerging industry challenge.