Investigation for Use of ‘Pin in Paste’ Reflow Process with Combination of Solder Preforms to Eliminate Wave Soldering
The Pin in Paste (PiP) technology is the process of soldering Pin through hole (PTH) components using the Surface Mount Technology (SMT) reflow process. The use of PiP process offers several advantages compared to the traditional wave soldering process. One of the primary advantages is lowering of cost due to the elimination of the wave soldering process and its associated tooling cost and potential handling damage. Another advantage is that with the wave soldering process,it is extremely difficult to achieve adequate holefill on thermally challenging thick Printed Circuit Boards (PCBs). However,by using PiP process with combination of solder preforms,it is possible to achieve adequate holefill and reliable solder joints for soldering PTH components.
The objective of this study is to investigate the use and limitations of machine-placed solid solder preforms during the top-side SMT reflow process for PTH components. An experiment was designed to investigate the following problems:
1) How much additional volume is provided by the combination of printed solder paste plus preforms in determining final barrel fill volume?
2) How far away from the hole can the paste and preform extend and still coalesce during reflow?
3) What is the optimum lead to hole ratio for the use of solder preforms?
4) What is the effect of pin protrusion on the PiP process?
5) What are the limitations in placing preforms within printed solder paste?
6) What are the design considerations required for the different / various PTH components to be suitable for the PiP process with solder preforms?
7) What is the effect of different types of solder masks on the PiP process?
The experiment was conducted on a 130 mil test vehicle using both tin-lead and lead-free materials and processes. The results of this designed experiment along with the inspection methods are presented and discussed in detail in this paper. The outcome of this study will thus provide process engineers extensive guidelines for implementing PiP technology with combination of solder preforms.