An Analytical Characterization and Comparison of Adhesion Test for PCBs
Interest in the adhesive strength of PCBs has recently come to the forefront of the industry. This has been driven by the advent of lead free soldering processes which severely stress the mechanical properties of the board. For sometime,the accepted test method for measuring adhesion in the PCB industry has been the widely used peel strength test. At the same time,it has been common knowledge within the industry that this technique has been less than adequate in guarding against delamination failures during reflow and wave soldering. In recognition of this deficiency,a new test was recently introduced and the test method is now a part of IPC 650; the so called “T260 Method” in which a thermal event is imposed that causes a delamination of the test specimen. The purpose here is to compare the stress field associated with a board delamination to that generated by the peel test and the T260 test.
This analysis will initially give attention to a first principals characterization of the stress field associated with a uniform,free expansion of a PCB,such as in the reflow process. If severe enough,this will result in a delamination. The stress fields produced by the Peel and T260 tests are then analyzed and compared to that of a free expansion. As suspected,the stress fields of the two test methods are significantly different. The stress field created by the T260 test has the same geometry as the free expansion,but a scale factor is required for a total correlation.
Finally a novel technique is suggested for characterizing the layer-to-layer structural integrity of a PCB does not suffer these drawbacks.