Dynamic Testing and Modeling for Solder Joint Reliability Evaluation
The behavior of BGA solder joints under dynamic loads has become more significant in recent years. This work explored test
methodologies for solder joint failure evaluation under dynamic loads. The objectives of this study were
• To evaluate the behavior of solder joints under a variety of strain rates as seen during both 4 point bend testing and
mechanical shock
• To try to quantify the shock levels present at solder joint failure to support ongoing solder joint reliability modeling
efforts
A test coupon and fixture developed for the four point bend test setup is reviewed. Testing was performed under different
strain rates and the results showed clearly that the solder joint failure is strongly strain rate dependent under mechanical
bending load on boards. This implies that the practice of low strain rate (quasi-static) test with dynamic amplification factor
for solder joint failures,such as the four point bend test,is not sufficient for dynamic prediction due to over-estimation of the
joint strength at low strain rate range. The finite element analysis revealed that the strain rate dependent material properties of
the solder play the key role of solder joint failure threshold.
Comparison of strain rates between the four point bend test and a more traditional mechanical shock test were made on a
desktop motherboard. These tests showed that the strain rate is much higher during the mechanical shock test than that seen
during the bend testing. A variable mass shock test and an incremental shock test procedure were developed to evaluate BGA
solder joint shock failures. In-situ solder joint continuity was monitored during the shock events. The results of these tests
give a good estimate of motherboard BGA solder joint robustness.
In addition,a shock test fixture and a test vehicle were developed similar to those used in the four point bend test. By using
the incremental shock test procedure outlined above,the acceleration level (G-level) at solder joint failure was obtained. This
information was input to the finite element dynamic analysis,the overall behavior of the test coupon during shock was
simulated and the solder joint failure force obtained. Failure analysis of the shocked boards revealed that PCB pad/FR4
disbond was the dominant failure mode for the tested eutectic solder joints. In addition,fracture at IMC between pad and
solder on the package side was observed.
In summary,a set of test and modeling methodology for solder joint reliability evaluation under dynamic load was developed
and validated and some recommendations are made as to the applicability of these test methods.