Reflow Soldering Equals Wave Soldering Plus One
Lead-free solder is more than a swap for SnPb and more than simply an alternative alloy. Five years after implementation discussion remains regarding which alloy is the best for which application. Alternative lead-free solders are available with doping of small amounts of elements to improve reliability. This study is compares Sn3,0Ag0,5Cu with low-silver Sn1,0Ag0,7Cu0,05NiGe and Sn0,7Cu0,05NiGe,a modified SnCu alloy.
A design of experiment was done to define the process window of the different alloys. Different flux preheat and solder temperatures were part of the experiment. For each alloy,the preferred parameters were defined to establish a reliable soldering process. The boards were soldered using these settings and reliability levels were tested. The test boards included different pad and barrel dimensions. This returns recommendations for designers to define the optimal pin-to-hole ratio for the different alloys.
For each alloy,the test boards were thermal cycled at -40C/+125C (30’/10”/30’) and aged at +125C for 1000 hours. The study included tensile strength measurements,intermetallic thickness growth,cross sections and visual inspection according to IPC standards.
The same alloys were used for reflow soldering. Solder paste with the same flux chemistry was used to perform reliability experiments. The presentation discusses the alloys’ performance. It also explains the benefits of adding small elements to an alloy and how to establish a compatible selection for reflow and wave alloys.