Effects of Lead-Free Surface Finishes on Press-Fit Connections
For decades,tin-lead has been used as the primary surface finish for compliant pins and plated through holes (PTH) of
printed circuit board (PCB) in press-fit connections. Therefore,most test results on press-fit performance are focused on the
tin-lead finishes for the connections. Due to the discontinuation of the use of lead in electric and electronic components,the
trend of using lead-free manufacturing for PCB’s and connectors is being vigorously pursued by the industry. The present
study is intended to evaluate press-fit connections using various lead-free finishes on compliant pins and PTH’s and then
compare to tin-lead finish. The lead-free finishes for the compliant pins are plated with matte and bright pure tin,and the
lead-free finishes for the PTH’s are electroplated Au,OSP,and immersion tin,Au,and Ag finishes.
In the design of experiments (DOE) of the current study,single pin tests were used to obtain the DOE outputs of insertion
and retention forces for eye-of-the-needle (EON) compliant pins in PTH’s. For all three EON finishes (two pure tin and one
tin-lead),the DOE results show that finished PTH size is the most important factor to determine the insertion force. The
insertion force is a strong inverted linear function of finished PTH size (i.e.,a larger force is required for a smaller finished
PTH size). The impact from pin installation/repair cycle is the second factor behind the finished PTH size. The finishes of
EON and PTH are only minor factors for the insertion force. In contrast to the insertion force,the retention force is rather flat
regarding the finished PTH size. The DOE results also indicate the EON finish is ranked as the number one factor to affect
the retention force. The matte tin EON pin produces higher retention force than the tin-lead finish. The EON of bright tin
finish produces a slightly lower retention force than the tin-lead. Within the five lead-free and one tin-lead finishes for the
PTH’s in the study,the lead-free finishes of OSP,immersion Au and electroplated Au provide retention forces in the lower
end,and the immersion tin always provides the highest retention force. However,each of these combinations results in stable
electrical performance and a reliable connection.